Why Ethylene Oxide (EO) is Preferred for Syringe Sterilization Over Gamma Rays or High Temperature?
Sterilization of syringes demands a delicate balance between thorough microbial elimination, material compatibility, and preservation of functional integrity. Among various methods, ethylene oxide (EO) stands out as the preferred choice, while gamma rays and high-temperature sterilization face critical limitations. Here’s a detailed breakdown:
1. Core Advantages of Ethylene Oxide (EO) Sterilization
EO is a broad-spectrum sterilant that disrupts microbial proteins and nucleic acids through alkylation, achieving a sterility assurance level (SAL) of 10⁻⁶ (fewer than 1 viable microorganism in 1 million units). Its key strengths include:
Low-Temperature Operation Protects Materials Syringes are typically made of polypropylene (PP) or polyethylene (PE), polymers sensitive to high heat. EO sterilizes at 30–60°C, preventing material deformation, aging, or release of harmful substances. This preserves critical functions like seal integrity and smooth plunger movement.
Superior Penetration for Complex Structures Syringes feature intricate components—barrels, plungers, rubber gaskets, and tiny gaps. EO gas molecules, small in size, penetrate sealed packaging (e.g., paper-plastic pouches) and internal crevices, ensuring uniform sterilization. In contrast, high-temperature steam or gamma rays struggle to reach hidden microbes, leaving potential "sterility blind spots."
Broad Compatibility with Auxiliary Materials Pre-filled syringes (e.g., insulin pens) or those with rubber gaskets/lubricants (e.g., silicone oil) rely on EO’s minimal chemical impact. Unlike high heat (which denatures drugs) or gamma rays (which degrade rubber), EO preserves drug stability, rubber elasticity, and lubricant functionality.
2. Limitations of Gamma Ray Sterilization
Gamma rays (typically from cobalt-60) destroy microbial DNA but pose risks for syringes:
Material Degradation Polymers like PP undergo chain scission under gamma radiation, becoming brittle and less impact-resistant. This increases the risk of syringe breakage during use, especially for reusable models.
Functional Impairment Radiation weakens rubber gaskets’ elasticity, causing increased plunger resistance or seal failure. It also destabilizes lubricants, compromising smooth operation.
High Costs and Rigid Infrastructure Gamma sterilization requires specialized radiation sources and shielding, making it capital-intensive and suitable only for large-scale, single-type production—poorly suited for small-batch or multi sizes of syringes.
3. Why High-Temperature Sterilization Fails for Syringes
Methods like autoclaving (121–134°C) are ineffective here due to:
Heat Sensitivity of Materials While PP/PE melting points (130–170°C) exceed autoclave temperatures, prolonged heat causes creep (permanent deformation). This distorts barrel calibrations, enlarges diameters, and ruins dose accuracy .
Instability of Auxiliary Components Rubber gaskets harden, and silicone oil degrades under high heat, leading to plunger jamming or lubricant loss—critical failures in syringe performance.
Incompatibility with Sealed Packaging Syringes require sterile packaging post-sterilization, but autoclave steam damages seals. Drying steps after sterilization also add production time and costs.
4. EO’s Irreplaceability in Medical Standards
Medical device sterilization mandates three non-negotiables: thoroughness, material safety, and functional preservation. EO excels in all:
Unmatched Sterility EO eliminates even heat-resistant spores, meeting strict medical-grade requirements.
Controllable Residues Though toxic, EO residuals are reduced to safe levels (<10μg/g per FDA standards) via 48–72 hours of aeration, ensuring patient safety.
Flexibility EO works with diverse packaging and syringe size，adapting to small-batch or customized production.
Conclusion Ethylene oxide’s low-temperature operation, superior penetration, and broad compatibility make it ideal for syringes. Gamma rays’ material damage and high heat’s functional risks render them unsuitable, solidifying EO as the global standard for sterilizing polymer-based syringes.
With over 18 years history till now, we have became professional in the production and development of syringes and infusion set production molds, machines and other necessary equipment.
